“Double-secret probation” has been brought to an end at Georgia Tech.
The Phi Delta Theta fraternity is no “Animal House.” And Tech President Bud Peterson is no Dean Wormer. Nonetheless, it is safe to say that arguments over frat-house behavior and student justice rarely spill over into the holy confines of the state Capitol.
But that’s what’s happening. And the fraternity may be winning.
Last August, an African-American woman lodged a complaint against Phi Delta Theta, alleging that members of the fraternity shouted racial slurs at her from the windows of their campus house.
The fraternity denied that any such thing happened. It produced security video of the young woman walking by, unflinching. Windows from which the slurs were alleged to have been hurled had been sealed for years.
Even so, two months later, a Tech administrator in charge of student discipline placed the fraternity and its 100 or so members on “suspension in abeyance,” restricting its members to academic activities – no intramural sports, no socials — and requiring members to undergo sensitivity training as a condition for lifting the sanction.
No appeal was allowed, to either the Tech president or the state Board of Regents.
“Double-secret probation,” snarled Earl Ehrhart, a state representative from west Cobb County, who entered the picture shortly afterward.
Ehrhart is the same fellow who went after Delta Air Lines’ scalp last year when CEO Richard Anderson used some unfortunate language while encouraging the Legislature to pass a tax increase to rebuild the state’s roads and bridges. At Ehrhart’s urging, Delta lost a 10-year-old sales tax break on aviation fuel, worth more than $20 million a year.
Ehrhart is also chairman of the House Appropriations subcommittee that oversees university spending. The Cobb County lawmaker has previously expressed his doubts about the way Georgia’s public universities handle accusations of sexual assault – whether they might be better handled by law enforcement and qualified prosecutors.
(An Atlanta Journal-Constitution investigation this month found that Tech had recently been ordered to re-instate a student who had been unfairly accused of sexual assault.)
Likewise, the Tech fraternity’s suspension riled Ehrhart. “These young men have lost an entire half-year of their college experience. It’s a huge sanction. You spend a lot of time and effort and money to get into a fraternity,” the lawmaker said. “And they’re walking around campus with a scarlet letter on their foreheads, for ‘racists.’”
For the last three months, Ehrhart, Georgia Tech officials, the state Board of Regents, and attorneys for members of the aggrieved fraternity have argued and negotiated. Ehrhart has issued threats of reduced – or at least capped – funding for the engineering university.
In December, a special committee set up to examine student disciplinary policies issued its report to Peterson, the Tech president. Among its findings: While facts were undisputed in “95 percent” of all disciplinary investigations, in “one case,” punishment was meted out solely on the force a statement by the person who lodged the complaint. No other evidence was considered.
That case, Ehrhart said, targeted the Phi Delta Theta fraternity.
On Monday, Ehrhart will hold a two-hour hearing in the Capitol. He will announce that the Board of Regents are working on a system-wide policy to ensure due process for university students. In other words, tuition and other amenities, once paid for, are a property right that shouldn’t be ripped away lightly.
Likewise, Tech has been ordered to cease its practice of denying appeals in “suspension by abeyance” cases. A spokeswoman for the Board of Regents confirmed both developments.
Ehrhart also said the Tech administrator who had overseen student disciplinary issues had been transferred.
But the lawmaker won’t get one thing he wanted.
Ehrhart said he has demanded that the complaint against the fraternity be dropped. It hasn’t been. Instead Phi Delta Theta will be allowed to make an appeal to an appointed jurist, former state Supreme Court chief justice Leah Sears. Evidence will be allowed. Lawyers, too. Ehrhart wasn’t impressed.
“You want to talk about ‘safe space’? In the vernacular of campus discussion today, there’s no safe space for young men at Tech. You want to be safe? Go to class, then go run and hide in your dorm. That’s where we are at Tech right now,” said Ehrhart, who can be prone to operatic pronouncements.
The Tech student body is roughly 70 percent male. Incidents on the other side of the scale have been documented. For instance, the email that surfaced in 2013, in which the social chair of another Tech fraternity instructed his brothers on how to lure “rapebait” by getting female guests drunk.
Ehrhart said Monday’s hearing will include testimony from an attorney for Phi Delta Theta. University system officials have been invited, as have Tech officials. But the lawmaker offered a warning, with Wagnerian overtones.
”This is not a micro-aggression. This is a macro-aggressive environment when Earl Ehrhart is chairing the meeting. If you don’t like someone to disagree with you, little snowflake, and you’re going to melt in a fetal position on the floor of my committee room, you can go outside in the hall,” he said. “It’s a public building, but you can’t do it there when adults are having a conversation.”







"Fake Rape" didn't start with Tech, or U Va's Jackie, or even Twana Brawley. It was cooked up by Berkeley Marxists to create chaos at least as far back as the mid 80s.
In the 70s Tech had a string of actual rapes and as I remember the fraternities organized escorts to walk the few women on campus from the Student Center to the dorms at night. Of course it turned out the perps were thugs from the then Techwood Housing Projects. So.....shhhhhh........
The only change since then is Tech has acquired a parasite known as the Ivan Allen School of Liberals and Artists to expend State and alumni funds preparing students for a bright future in feminist narratology, Frankfurt Marxism, yard care, fast food service, and apparently fake rape.
When Peterson came around banging his tin cup, I told him I send my money to Africa where it might actually do some good.
Russell Fish EE74
Ah, there is video of this NOT happening? Where are the sanctions against this false accuser? She should be expelled, possibly have her head examined.
@pseudogoth You didn't read the report. The video only shows a person walking outside, it does NOT show the Delta gang lair or the activities there-in. Anybody who has been to any University knows what goes on in these rape houses. They even instruct their pledges in how to lure prospective victims and force them to perform as entertainment. Where have you been? 'Animal House' barely touched the surface of what crimes a real fraternity-gang commits.
@Ralph-45 @pseudogoth @Ralph-45 @pseudogoth Hey brother. I'm part of these "rape-houses" and my friends, male and female alike say they feel safer here than they do anywhere else on campus at night. Now given how you answered it's obvious you don't go here. And don't have any experience with Tech's campus or history. Yes the Rape-Bait email was a black mark, made by one person. And the entire fraternity got punished for it. But person doesn't stereotype an entire group, I'm jsure you can agree with that. That being said I'm sure you can also agree that everyone deserves to be treated equally, fair according to the eyes of the law and people alike.
@Ralph-45 @pseudogoth I've been to a University. Got my B.S. in Biology at one and an M.S. in Biochemistry at another. I lived in a fraternity where I got my B.S. and none of this crap you're talking about ever happened there. Did the guys all want to get laid? Sure. Were they all looking for meaningful relationships? Nope. This made them exactly zero different from the non-fraternity guys who went to school there, and frankly little different from most of the girls. We had parties, girls came in, occasionally someone scored, but nobody got raped. Any guy who had forced a girl to do something against her will would have been tossed out.
You obviously don't know a damn thing about fraternities - all you've done is read things written by someone with an agenda. Spend some time talking to actual people who have lived in fraternities or admit you don't really know what you're talking about.
@Ralph-45 @pseudogoth "gang lair"? Really?
"Anybody who has been to any University knows..." Ralph-45 actually did go to a university - he drove through campus that one time by accident.
@Ralph-45 @pseudogoth
The fraternity is guilty of making racial threats because"everybody" knows what there are gang lair activities going on? You, sir, are a deranged bozo.
"Adults are having a conversation"? " If you don’t like someone to disagree with you, little snowflake, and you’re going to melt in a fetal position on the floor of my committee room, you can go outside in the hall,”?
Is this what we expect from a paid Georgia official? He sounds a lot like a Trumpett - another small group about to be expelled from civil society.
Flush this whole stinky mess. If there is a crime - report it to the police. If there is violation of the Georgia Tech honor code, investigate it and expel the violators. The first step should be consideration of the elimination of youth gangs - for example, the Delta 'fraternity'.
@Ralph-45 That's what's happening. The fraternity is reporting a violation of the honor code and the law, and the person spearheading the oppression against the fraternities got removed.
Now in regards to youth gangs, as you keep putting it. I'm trying to figure out where your are getting these ideas from. Statistics show that people in fraternities and sororities statistically do better academic wise and have higher graduate rates.
@Ralph-45 Yes. It's exactly what one should expect from a paid Georgia official. It's about time that the legislatures of every State in this country realized that their State universities have gone overboard pandering to a bunch of whiny children who think they get to control what other people think by controlling what they say - trying to claim they're injured by things people say that they disagree with or that doesn't affirm what they think. It's time some adult supervision was applied to both the students and the faculties and administrations of all public universities and remind them they are accountable to the public at large and their representatives.
@Ralph-45 Youth gangs? That's YOUR neighborhood.
It is situations like this one which makes parents openly wonder now if the cost of higher education in America is worth it. What sane parent wants to see his child indoctrinated with an entirely un-American culture, much less have to fork over tens of thousands of dollars for that "privilege!"
It is frankly time that university academia be given an object lesson in common sense and Constitutional principles. But, one wonders how many of them even acknowledge the existence of the Constitution, much less comprehend its true meaning.
Bud Peterson, his overpaid "consultants" and so called administrators need to go. He is bad for the Institute.
The issue the article fails to cover is how Obama's DOE has extorted schools into depriving male students of their due process rights. That is the well from which all of this springs and it is the background that is necessary to understand why all of this is happening now.
People are upset that this representative is pushing back with funding threats etc... but the original threat came from the Department of Education which illegally threatened to withhold federal funding from any university which did not deprive students of their due process rights. People are being punished without any chance to confront their accuser or present evidence on their own behalf. And as we see here, many people are being punished even when it is clear that they are innocent. At another university there was even a young man who was found innocent by both a criminal court and a campus review board who was still not allowed to attend class. People are being ruined on the basis of nothing more than an allegation. Even the Salem Witch Trials had more protections for the accused than do the procedures at many of our colleges.
These abuses have to stop. And there have to be consequences for those who have put these policies in place. At some point universities have to have some sort of adult supervision and it sounds like steps are being taken to make sure that is the case.
You can try to make this a man/woman, black/white issue. That is certainly what the people pushing these policies want. But due process rights are important to everyone whether black, white, man, woman or child. You don't get to claim to be a good person or to be morally superior if you support these sorts of abuses. You are simply up to no good and are seeking power for certain groups at the expense of others in the mistaken belief that your group will always be the beneficiary. History says you are a fool to think such a thing.
@Ben Franklin Ah, I knew there would be an "It is Obama's Fault" statement. Question if a tree falls in the woods, and nobody sees or hears it; is that Obama's fault as well?
@Calliope @Ben Franklin Did one of Obama's administrative departments issue a formal "Dear Colleague" letter addressing trees falling in woods?
Go ahead, snowflake. Google "Dear Colleague Letter". And put an end to your ignorance.
Finally, wealthy heterosexual white males have a voice. God bless this representative!
@Wrecker
Try to keep up cupcake, my statement is ironic because they have and will continue to have every advantage in this great country. The idea that an elected representative is consuming his time with such things is what's ridiculous.
@Jerry916
Ostensibly heterosexual....if the walls of those fraternity houses could talk, I am certain they might tell a different story.
@ssinf Have a voice? All anyone can hear these days is Donald Trump and his contingent of ugly wealthy heterosexual white males bellowing down sane voices. Big deal. They have had their day and screwed it up royally. The majority is tired of the stench.
@ssinf where do you read that they are heterosexual?
@Ron Chris
Those many advances thanks to the Arabic numeral system. By your logic we should really be thanking the Arabs for our existence.....
That of course would be assuming that white males are responsible for every scientific and technological advance in history....which would of course be silly to assume. The first successful open heart surgery was performed by a black dude, for instance. But hey, let's not let the historical record cloud your own bias. I won't even trouble you with the interesting tale of Henrietta Lacks.
@WTHWTHWTH
I see, not getting the outcome you want now means you were denied due process.
It's almost insulting to the many, many people who don't come from means and get screwed in the real justice system, and actually serve real prison time, not just the inconvenience of having their little club suspended for a couple of semester.
The irony, the same people who claim there is no due process here, are perfectly ok with a 12 year old black kid being gunned down by police within seconds of their arrival on the scene.
@jaggar1 @WTHWTHWTH @ssinf @Wrecker
Maybe some of you here feeling outraged over suspension from social club activities could feel some empathy with a race kidnapped from their country, enslaved, and denied rights for generations who did not have powerful politicians to intervene on their behalves.
I understand 2 wrongs if that turns out to be the case, but imagine the economic and emotional scars your family would bear today if 2 generations ago they couldn't go to school with or drink from the same water fountain as the "good" people.
@Ron Chris Actually, they have successfully stuffed their pockets and left half the world's human race with inadequate food, healthcare, and water. Do some reading. That 3rd world you are referring to was created by greed, slavery, withholding of education, etc. I don't see that another golf course or Trump tower is designed to help that situation or that fraternities are producing anybody leading corrections of these denials.
@Ron Chris @ssinf
Yes and look what they did for the cotton industry in the south - all by their white selves.
@ssinf Did you read the article? About the part where no evidence was allowed to be submitted by the accused in their defense, and no evidence was required from the accuser?
@ssinf
No, being denied the right to present evidence in your own defense, being denied adequate time to defend yourself before being declared guilty, and being denied the right to appeal the sentence means that you were denied due process.
Constitutional rights apply to everyone: white, black, hispanic, male, females, transgender, straight, gay, bisexual, etc. You don't get to pick and choose who deserves due process and who doesn't just because you don't like them. That makes you no better than a member of a lynch mob a century ago.
Need I point out that the OSI kangaroo court also expelled a gay student and denied him the same right of due process?
@ssinf @Ron Chris Henrietta Lacks - who just got some cells taken from her and didn't have to know anything or lift a finger - yep, she sure did make a massive contribution...
@Ralph-45 @Ron Chris The 3rd world I refer to is the natural state of humanity without benefit of enlightened Western European ideals or culture. If it were not for those, humans would live with slavery, murder, and might makes right being the way of things.
@ssinf Yeah damn those hetero white males and their vaccines and computers and electricity and refrigerators and air conditioning and airplanes and space travel and open heart surgery and cancer treatments.
What have they ever done for us?!?
@AvgGeorgian @jaggar1 @WTHWTHWTH @ssinf @Wrecker I KNEW somebody would finally mention slavery. I just wonder why it took AvgGeorgian so long to make his whine heard
@WTHWTHWTH @ssinf @Wrecker Everyone should have due process. We are now in a time period where if blacks complain racism, which is every day, everyone should bow down and pander to them. We need to stop being so politically correct and allow due process. Just like those Duke players who were thrown out of school and portrayed as guilty when that disgusting woman lied. Imagine that! A black hooker lying and everyone pandered to her, and Duke ruined the lives of all those kids. We are in a sad world!
@Ralph-45 @ssinf Actually the vast majority of the human race is doing millions of times better than if wealthy hetero white males had not been in charge. And where other people are in charge or the cultures of other societies or other governing ideas are in place - things are objectively far worse than where the Western Europeans are in charge. So if you want society to decline to 3rd world degeneracy, feel free to keep on with your racist white-bashing and sexist male-bashing.
@ssinf " the arabic numeral system " ??? WTF ?
you mean shoot one/ bomb two/ bury three ?
@ssinf @Wrecker No it's not - stupid doen not equal ironic
@AvgGeorgian @Ron Chris @ssinf Eli Whitney was not a white man? That's news to me.
@ssinf @WTHWTHWTH Tamir Rice did get due process. He waved around a gun and got processed.
@MensaGodzilla @ssinf @Wrecker Accusations of stupidity should be properly spelled.
@Ralph-45 @Ron Chris No, the 'Third World' is the natural state of man without the technical and political contributions of the white man.
@AvgGeorgian @jaggar1 @WTHWTHWTH @ssinf @Wrecker How are the victims of these past wrongs benefited by denying someone else their due process, and being guilty until proven innocent? Look around, the attempts to compensate the victims of slavery seem to have created as many problems as solutions.
@ssinf @Wrecker
If U.S citizens are being denied due process and are being declared guilty without evidence or appeal, then I would say that it is PRECISELY what an elected representative should be spending his time on.
@ssinf @Jerry916 I'm in one of these fraternites. We have several openly lgbt members. You'd be surprised to find us more progressive than you think. That is, if you stopped judging a book by it's cover.
@backstagepass @ssinf You are an idiot and not helping support us people in the fraternities. Please leave. (before you do go research our number system, cause @ssinf is quite right)
@ssinf @Wrecker The idea that an elected representative is consuming his time with a group of people being falsely accused, having their rights taken away on unsubstantiated accusations and denied access by un-elected bureaucrats paid by public money to due process is EXACTLY WHY WE HAVE ELECTED REPRESENTATIVES.
@AvgGeorgian @jaggar1 @WTHWTHWTH @ssinf @Wrecker At the same time that slavery was going on many of my Irish forebears couldn't go to school with the "white" people, couldn't work most jobs, were viewed as inferiors and drunks and had their religion mocked and even banned. Crimes against them were often not investigated and they were forced into taking the worst jobs. Many of them originally came to the U.S. as slaves, sold off as children.
Do I have sympathy to people who are victims of racism? Yes. Do I have sympathy to people who have overcome that enough to go to an excellent university and then make false accusations of racism against other people because of their race? That in and of itself is racism, and I have no sympathy for it regardless of their personal history or that of 2 generations ago.
@Ralph-45 @ssinf The vast majority of Trump's supporters are NOT wealthy by any means. You've missed entirely why Trump is popular - and it's the same reason why Sen. Sanders is so popular on the left. It's because establishment politicians on both sides of the aisle have stopped representing the public. Oh, when they're running for office they tell us what we want to hear. But once elected they believe they have been elevated to a "ruling class". They believe that they are smarter and more moral than the public and deserve to have power over the public. So they do what they figure is best for us regardless of what we actually tell them we want done - and one thing they are sure is the best thing for us is that they stay in power. But Sanders has long been an independent and Trump has never been a politician at all. Their supporters figure that they'll actually DO what they say they'll do. Of course, their supporters want different things done. But that's the base reason why so many people on the right back Trump and so many on the left back Sanders.
@ssinf @Ron Chris "The first successful open heart surgery was performed by a black dude, for instance."
That's right. One who had the good fortune of being born and raised in a country based on Western ideals of democracy, representative government, capitalism, etc., etc.
@ssinf Terrible.
I mean they're white AND heterosexual?
What more proof do we need that they're guilty of whatever crime we claim?
Video? I don't want facts, I want FEELZ!
Facts are for people who think; not good college liberals!
Does that sum it up,l or is there more idiocy you want to share?@Ralph-45 @ssinf
So the "sane' voices want to punish someone while ignoring evidence; because of their race?
Do we do that in all cases, or just when Mein Fuhrer decides that a race is guilty?
@ssinf Your ridiculous implication being that they should not have a say in any matter. Very progressive of you!